An accidental blog

"If God is sovereign, then his lordship must extend over all of life, and it cannot be restricted to the walls of the church or within the Christian orbit." Abraham Kuyper Common Grace 1.1.

Friday, 24 May 2024

Herman Bavinck’s review of Kuyper’s Encyclopaedia of Sacred Theology Volume 1 from Da Bazuin

 A quick and dirty, provisional translation.


Herman Bavinck. "Review of Encyclopaedie der Heilige Godgeleerdheid. Deel I, by A. Kuyper", De Bazuin 42:13 (1894).

Encyclopaedie der Heilige Godgeleerdheid. Deel I [Encyclopaedia of Sacred Theology], by Dr. A. Kuyper. Part I, Introductory part. Amsterdam, Wormser 1894.

This Encyclopaedia, as we read in the preface, stands on the principles of Reformed theology, which the author professes with full conviction. For this reason alone, the appearance of this work is an event that will not fail to make its impact felt within and outside the circle of Reformed churches. There was no shortage of encyclopaedias of various principles and directions. There was a pressing need for a Reformed Encyclopaedia, and this need was felt more deeply as time went on.

By encyclopaedia, one understands that science which chooses science itself as the object of its research and reflection. This meaning of the encyclopaedia is demonstrated comprehensively and clearly in the first 50 pages of this part. The name, the idea, and the concept of the encyclopaedia are discussed successively, and then the concept of the Theological Encyclopaedia is developed.

From this, the great importance of this science and also of the work that Dr. Kuyper brings to light is already apparent. The deepest questions of science, the principles of Theology, are discussed. The task of the encyclopaedia is to make us aware of the sciences' principles, objects, goals, and coherence. Science is also an organic whole with its own life. The encyclopaedia attempts to trace that life; to highlight the members of that organism, i.e., the various fields in their organic connection; and to identify and combat the errors and shortcomings that also occur in this organism.

The general encyclopaedia attempts to do this with science as a whole. The specialized encyclopaedias, of law, letters, etc., do this concerning a particular group of fields or sciences that are organically related. Among these, the Theological Encyclopaedia strives to make us understand the organism of Sacred Theology in its principles and coherence.

Therefore, encyclopaedic study is an indispensable requirement for anyone who strives not merely for knowledge and scholarship but for science in the true sense. In it, science first comes to full self-awareness, reflecting on its own nature and essence. It is the ultimate, the highest, the science of sciences.

We cannot be grateful enough to the esteemed author for this work. He was the designated man for it, both in breadth and depth of vision. Moreover, this work also has current relevance. Little has been done in our circles in terms of encyclopaedic study. Hagenbach briefly glanced at the beginning of theological study to get an overview of the number of fields and the literature that had appeared on them. But there was hardly any real study. This certainly explains the misunderstandings and confusion about the principles and essence of Theology in our circles. Everyone thinks of Theology in their own way. Dr. Kuyper's work, especially the second and third parts, will undoubtedly provide the necessary clarification on many questions.

Of course, this does not mean that from now on, one should simply accept this work and say yes and amen to everything the author asserts and claims. A work like this is not primarily intended to be learned and parroted, but to be studied and thoughtfully considered. The greatest blessing from this work will come if the rich and deep thoughts of the author stimulate our own thinking and lead us to independent insight and judgment.

Nevertheless, this Encyclopaedia will promote agreement on the principles and fundamental ideas of Theology among us. The author's insight into the true character of Reformed Theology is so accurate that anyone who has studied it to some extent cannot withhold their agreement.

Therefore, it is to be hoped that all our students and ministers will acquire this work. Fifteen guilders is quite an expense for many, but the price is extremely low for such a comprehensive scientific work. And by owning such a work, one gains access to many other books and brochures.

The first part, after dealing with the concept of the encyclopaedia, extensively covers the history of this science. It testifies to enormous diligence. The search for and mastery of many books necessary for this must have cost a great deal of effort. A whole series of authors on the encyclopaedia passes before our eyes. One might almost say it was "too much of a good thing." But a somewhat complete history of this field had not yet been given. And in the evaluation of each author, not only does Dr. Kuyper's own standpoint become clear, but also the relationship in which he stands in other directions. Furthermore, the appreciative tone, even in serious criticism, is striking. Everywhere, the voice of the true scholar is heard, who is solely concerned with the truth. This will also contribute to the appreciation of his work in wide circles. Finally, the style is never dull or dry, but vigorous, clear, and captivating from beginning to end. May it find many readers and win many disciples for the Reformed principles.

H. BAVINCK.





Tuesday, 14 May 2024

Roy Clouser is interviewed by Paul Vanderkley

 


See the full interview here: https://youtu.be/60HfvocGnVg?si=XtWyjkJxM4M7N_ax


Herman Bavinck’s review of Kuyper’s The Work of the Holy Spirit from Da Bazuin

Herman Bavinck’s review of Kuyper’s The Work of the Holy Spirit

In a series of pieces in the De Bazuin [The Trumpet],* Herman Bavinck provided brief reviews of the three volumes of Kuyper’s Het Werk van den Heiligen Geest. These are provisional, quick and dirty translations.



Herman Bavinck “Review of Het Werk van den Heiligen Geest, by A. Kuyper (deel I)”, De Bazuin 36 (25) (1888):

Het werk van den Heiligen Geest. [The Work of the Holy Spirit ] By Dr. A. Kuyper. 
Eerste deel. 
Amsterdam, Wormser.

In this work, which will be complete in three volumes and then cost 17.50, we are offered a reprint of the extensive series of articles that Dr. Kuyper wrote in De Heraut about the work of the Holy Spirit, along with two pieces that appeared in the De Heraut under their own titles (Sanctification and Love) but are now included as a third part under the work of the H. G. [?] will be included.

The author now precedes the entire work with a preface of 30 pages. Therein, we receive a complete list of Owen's works; a list of works written earlier and later on the Holy Spirit; and a repeated refutation of Dr. [Eduard] Böhl [1836-1903)]. 

We now announce this new work by Dr. Kuyper with only a few words. Perhaps we will return to the content later; there is certainly enough in it that deserves discussion and about which the Reformed theologians have not unanimously agreed.

May this writing contribute to a better understanding and appreciation of the work of the Holy Spirit! 

H. B.



 
Herman Bavinck “Review of Het Werk van den Heiligen Geest, by A. Kuyper (deel II)”, De Bazuin 37 (8) (1889):

The work of the Holy Spirit in the individual. 
The first part of this book deals with the work of the Holy Spirit for the church as a whole; the recently published second part discusses the work of the Holy Spirit in the individual.

It successively discussed the work in humanity before the fall, in the sinner at regeneration, calling and conversion, justification and faith. Recommendation of these studies, already known from De Heraut, is unnecessary; announcement of a work by the esteemed author's hand is sufficient. It is not necessary to agree with Dr. Kuyper on everything, for example, on regeneration, calling, justification, etc., to also claim the name of Reformed. The path that Dr. K. has taken and continues with so much talent is not the only one that runs through Reformed Theology. However, even with differences of opinion, there is much to learn from this work. Therefore, we wish it to be in many hands. Mr. Wormser has ensured a neat publication.

B.



 
Herman Bavinck “Review of Het Werk van den Heiligen Geest, by A. Kuyper (deel III)", De Bazuin 38 (2) (1890):

[The Work of the Holy Spirit, by Dr. A. Kuyper. Part III, in the individual.] 
Amsterdam, J. A. Wormser. 

This, the third and final part of Dr. Kuyper's study on the work of the Holy Spirit, has long awaited an announcement in the Bazuin. Fortunately, this important work, unlike many brochures, does not lose its value with each passing day but retains its significance for years to come. With this part, the study of the prolific writer on the work of the Holy Spirit is completed. Specifically, in this final part, Sanctification, Love, and Prayer are successively discussed. Of these three pieces, we consider the first to be the most important. In it, Sanctification is once again clearly explained, in accordance with the teaching of Scripture and the Reformed confession, and defended against various errors that have crept into this part of the truth. But the other two essays, on love and prayer, are also instructive and edifying. We do not need to provide a detailed account of the content, as readers will likely remember it from De Heraut. The convenient format and clear printing in which these articles are now presented, in conjunction with their intrinsic value, will undoubtedly prompt many to decide to acquire this work. The work as a whole is an enrichment of our theological literature. The subject, too often overlooked and neglected in earlier times, tugs at the hearts of every Reformed believer. The thorough treatment and clear presentation make it a book rich in learning and comfort for both the simple and the learned. And an index, both of topics and persons, as well as Bible verses, facilitates its use. May this work of the learned author therefore find wide circulation and thus contribute to ever greater appreciation of the work of the Holy Spirit!



* Da Bazuin was subtitled: Voices from the Christian Reformed Church in the Netherlands. (For the benefit of the Theological School in Kampen.)



 

Saturday, 6 April 2024

Findings 6 (March 2024)

 





Available from here


Issue 6, March 2024

Chris Gousmett Editorial – Misplaced Piety and the Denigration of  Creation

Richard A. Russell Is Karl Barth’s Christocentrism a valid Christian way of theological thinking?

Steve Bishop Jenő Sebestyén – The Hungarian Kuyper

Jenő Sebestyén Dr Abraham Kuyper – a translation of the Introduction to the Hungarian edition of “Lectures on Calvinism”

Richard Middleton Our postmodern moment: The Biblical Metanarrative

David Neville Book Review: J Richard Middleton: Abraham’s Silence

Chris van Haeften On the same page: Dooyeweerd on law and subject

Steve Bishop Kuyper Bibliography

Steve Bishop Dooyeweerd Bibliography

Friday, 5 April 2024

Faith in Law, Law in FaithFaith in Law, Law in Faith: Reflecting and Building on the Work of John Witte, Jr.

 


Faith in Law, Law in Faith: Reflecting and Building on the Work of John Witte, Jr.

Editors: Rafael Domingo, Gary S. Hauk, and Timothy P. Jackson

Across four decades, John Witte, Jr. has advanced the study of law and religion by retrieving religious sources of law, renewing timeless teachings of religion for today, and reengaging with the difficult issues confronting society. Interdisciplinary, international, and interfaith in scope, Witte’s work has generated an enormous body of scholarship. This collection of essays by leading scholars examines his impact and maps new directions for future exploration.


Open access available here.

Friday, 23 February 2024

“Everything matters” Gordon Spykman

 My paper on Gordon Spykman has now been published:


Bishop, Steve (2024) "Everything Matters: Gordon Spykman - A Neo-Calvinist Theologian," Pro Rege: Vol. 52: No. 3, 1 - 15.

Available at: https://digitalcollections.dordt.edu/pro_rege/vol52/iss3/1



Monday, 11 December 2023

Herman Bavinck: “All of God’s creation is good … “

 Herman Bavinck from The Problem of War:


But it is all the more striking that Christianity is devoid of all asceticism and from its very beginning took on a positive relationship to the world at large. This fact is principally found in the statement that God loved the world and that Christ came not to destroy the world but to save it. From this focal point lines are drawn in all directions to indicate the place Christians are to occupy and the attitudes they are to have in this sinful world. They must not withdraw from the world, but being in the world they are to keep themselves from the evil one. Nothing is unclean of itself. All God's creation is good and nothing is to be rejected if it be accepted with thanksgiving. Marriage is honorable among all. The government is God's servant and is entitled to obedience and respect. Whoever becomes a Christian is to remain in the calling to which he was called. The prayer of Jesus' disciples is that God's name be hallowed, that His kingdom come, that His will be done on earth as it is in Heaven. All this points, not to an avoidance, but to a sanctification of the world.


Translated by Stephen Voorwinde. The Banner of Truth (July-August 1977): 46–53.

Wednesday, 27 September 2023

Roques & Yeadon on a Dooyeweerdian approach to evangelism

 Yeadon, M. & Roques, M., 2023. Mr Dooyeweerd, Modal Aspects and Dynamic Evangelism. KOERS — Bulletin for Christian Scholarship, 88(1). Available at: https://doi. org/10.19108/KOERS.88.1.2528




Saturday, 9 September 2023

Origin of the term neo-Calvinism pre 1855?

The term neo-Calvinism is becoming more and more popular as this ngram of the number of usages of the term in books in the Google database shows:



 

The earliest known use of the noun neo-Calvinism is in the 1850s according to the Oxford English Dictionary. It suggests that it stems from 1854, in the writing of J. Guthrie.

The reference it gives is J. Guthrie in Evang. Union Worthies

The Revd John Guthrie had died in 1839, so the article is a brief biography of him, not by him as the OED suggests.

I couldn’t find an 1854 version, but the 1883 The Worthies of the Evangelical Union Being the Lives and Labours of Deceased Evangelical Union Ministers; Illustrated with Portraits has this:


 

However, the first mention cannot have been in 1883 as a paper by a Mr Rutherford with the title “Calvinism and Neo-Calvinism, or the Divine intention in the Atonement” is mentioned.

This is from The Evangelical Repository - Volumes 1-2 - Page 106 published in 1855. Presumably by a Mr Guthrie.



This, of course pre-dates Kuyper and how the term is used today. The first mention of the term applying to the approach of Kuyper and Bavinck et al appears to be in an 1887 review of Wilhelm Geesink’s Calvinisten in Holland by by J. Reitsma (George Harinck, “Herman Bavinck and the Neo-Calvinist Concept of the French Revolution,” in  James Eglinton and George Harinck (eds) Neo-Calvinism and French Revolution (London: Bloomsbury, 2016), 21 fn 43. The term originally had negative connotations, but Anne Anema (1872-1966) used it as a convenient term to describe the movement and the term stuck. (Anne Anema, Calvinisme en rechtswetenschap: een studie (Amsterdam, 1897), p. xvi.)